Beating trays and the Mann–Whitney U test
Required technique ST5 · 3.1 The living environment · Spec 3.1.2, MS 1.9
Aim: Compare the number of invertebrates on a native tree (oak) and an introduced tree (sycamore) with beating trays, and test the difference with a Mann–Whitney U test.
Do it in the virtual lab: choose the kit, plan the method, take your own readings, then use your results and answer exam questions. Every run gives new readings.
Revise this practical
Equipment
Show the kit
- Beating tray: A white sheet on a frame held under a branch: animals knocked off land on it.
- Stick: Hits the branch a set number of times.
- Pooter: Collects small animals from the tray without harming them.
- Collecting pots: Hold the animals while you count them.
- Identification key: To check that what you count are invertebrates.
Method
Show the method
- Choose 8 branches at random on each tree, all at about the same height.
- Hold the beating tray under the first branch.
- Hit the branch sharply 5 times with the stick.
- Use a pooter to collect the animals that fall onto the tray and count them.
- Release the animals back onto the tree, then repeat for every branch.
- Rank all the results together and carry out a Mann–Whitney U test.
The variables
Why use a Mann–Whitney U test here instead of a t-test?
Show answer
The counts are not normally distributed (most branches have few animals, a few have many)
Mann–Whitney compares two sets of data without needing a normal distribution.
Which is a control variable?
Show answer
The number of hits and the height of the branch
Different heights and numbers of hits would change the catch.
Why release the animals back onto the same tree?
Show answer
To reduce the impact on the habitat and the populations being studied
Practical work should minimise environmental impact.
Remember
- Beating tray (ST5): tray under the branch, a set number of hits, pooter, count and release.
- Mann–Whitney U: rank all data together; R₁ = sum of ranks of sample 1; U₁ = n₁n₂ + n₁(n₁ + 1)/2 − R₁; U₂ = n₁n₂ − U₁.
- Use the smaller U. Significant if U ≤ critical value (13 for 8 and 8 at p = 0.05).
- Native trees usually support more native invertebrates than introduced ones.
Exam-style questions
Why does native oak support more invertebrates than introduced sycamore?
Show answer
Many native insects have co-evolved with oak and can feed on it
Introduced species often support few native species.
What does a beating tray sample best?
Show answer
Invertebrates on tree and shrub branches
ST5: beating trays, sweep nets, light traps, bat detectors.
When is a Mann–Whitney U test used?
Show answer
To compare two sets of data that may not be normally distributed
At least 6 values in each set is a common rule.
Play next
- 🧪 Next: Bat detector and chi-squaredRequired technique ST5. Use a bat detector to count bat passes along a path with lit and dark sections, and test whether bats are spread evenly with a chi-squared test.
- 🧪 Previous: Sweep nets and Simpson's indexRequired technique ST5. Use a sweep net to sample invertebrates in a wildflower field margin and a sprayed field edge, and compare their diversity with Simpson's index.
- 🧪 All AQA A-level Environmental Science practicalsPractise every sampling technique (ST1 to ST6) and the statistics: kit, method, readings and exam questions.
- ❓ Ten question quiz: AQA revision gameTen quick questions from one topic or a whole course.
- ✏️ Crosswords: AQA revision gameFive per topic. Fill in the grid, then check your answers.
- 🃏 Pairs: AQA revision gameMatch each question card to its answer card. Pick your topics, how many cards and how hard.
- 🏝️ KN Island: revision gameRun an island for 12 years (14 in Examiner mode): every choice is real Environmental Science.
- 🔗 Associations: AQA revision gameLink eight key terms on a board and say why each pair goes together.
- 5️⃣ Five Degrees: AQA revision gameGet from one term to another in five steps or fewer, with a link that makes sense at every step.
- 🗂️ AQA A-level Environmental Science revisionEvery topic, with questions and answers, quizzes and crosswords.
